The combined message supports the dollar and keeps front-end Treasury yields firm, though markets aren’t chasing Waller’s call for a bigger move. That leaves room for a repricing if December data run hot. If Waller’s communication-first approach wins out, the risk is a more hawkish statement and press conference even with a 25bp hike, which could push expectations for the rate path higher. Gold faces a headwind from rising hike expectations, as it has throughout this cycle. Rate-sensitive AI and growth stocks remain exposed after a bruising week. Elevated oil prices are part of the inflation problem the hawks describe, so energy remains the swing factor for how far they push.
—
Wednesday’s Fed speakers agreed that inflation needs more work. The only real disagreement is pace: Waller wants a bigger hike or much tougher guidance, while the rest appear content with steady quarter-point steps.
Summary:
- Governor Waller favours a 50bp hike in December or much tougher forward guidance to break the public’s acceptance of 3% inflation
- Waller noted that about 70% of core services components are running above 3% and said the Fed may need to go beyond reversing last year’s cuts
- Kashkari said markets expect more hikes than officials do and stressed keeping inflation expectations anchored
- Daly said inflation has been too high for too long, with spending resilient even among lower-income households
- Barr supports further hikes if the economy evolves as expected but gave no timetable
- Markets price about 61bp of hikes over three meetings, with only around a 5% chance of a 50bp move in December
Four Federal Reserve policymakers lined up on Wednesday to argue that the fight against inflation is not finished, with Governor Christopher Waller going furthest by making the case for a 50 basis point hike in December. Minneapolis Fed President Neel Kashkari, San Francisco Fed President Mary Daly and Governor Michael Barr all leaned the same way, pointing to inflation that has stayed too high for too long against a backdrop of resilient spending and a stable jobs market. Together, their remarks reinforce expectations that the Fed will raise rates again next month, with the debate now centred on how hard to push rather than whether to move.
Waller: break the 3% psychology
Waller set out the most aggressive view. He is worried that price pressures have spread well beyond energy, noting that roughly 70% of the components in the core services basket are running above 3%. He sees businesses growing comfortable passing higher costs on to customers, partly because they believe consumers can absorb them, and fears the public is starting to accept inflation around 3% as normal after years above the Fed’s 2% target.
To break that psychology, Waller believes the Fed needs to act more forcefully, either by raising rates by 50 basis points in December or by signalling a markedly tougher stance through statements, press conferences and forward guidance. He suggested the Fed may need to go beyond simply reversing the rate cuts it made last year, and questioned how useful the December economic projections will be, preferring sharper forward-looking communication. Waller is, for now, alone among governors in pushing for a bigger move, but his views have often been an early signal of where policy goes next.
Kashkari: markets see more hikes than officials do
Kashkari’s most striking comment was that markets believe the Fed will need to raise rates further than officials currently expect, and he made no effort to talk that pricing down. He traced elevated inflation to a series of supply shocks and said keeping inflation expectations anchored is essential. He described the strength of demand as somewhat surprising and the job market as resilient, and said higher rates can clearly weigh on investment.
Daly described the labour market as stable but lacking dynamism, with employment broad-based and helped by a revival in manufacturing. She said consumer spending remains resilient, even among lower-income households, and that inflation has been too high for too long, while acknowledging uncertainty over how it will evolve. Last week she said further hikes were likely needed, citing inflation spreading into services, though she also noted early signs of consumer fatigue and plans to watch holiday spending closely.
Barr: more hikes if the outlook holds
Barr said he would support further rate increases if the economy evolves as he expects, calling inflation too high and a strain on many households. He described the economy as strong with low unemployment and said returning inflation to 2% in a timely way is critical, though he declined to commit to a timetable.
What markets are pricing
Markets were pricing around 61 basis points of hikes over the next three meetings, consistent with a quarter point move in December and more to follow. A 50 basis point step in December, however, was given only about a 5% chance, suggesting traders see Waller’s call as a warning shot rather than the base case. Minutes of the Fed’s last meeting, released on Wednesday, were reported to show officials expect further hikes and are concerned that AI investment could add to inflation, which fits the tone set by all four speakers.
The collective noun for hawks seems to be a “Fed” right now.
This article was written by Eamonn Sheridan at investinglive.com.